London, England - Everton winger Iliman Ndiaye (25) found himself at the center of a heated debate this weekend after receiving a yellow card for his goal celebration against Brighton. The incident has sparked outrage among fans and pundits alike, who argue that Ndiaye's actions were harmless and that the punishment was excessive.

Ndiaye's celebration involved flapping his arms like wings after scoring the winning goal from a penalty kick. Referee Tim Robinson deemed the gesture to be an imitation of a seagull, Brighton's team mascot, and issued a yellow card for what he perceived as a provocative act.

However, many have questioned the logic behind the decision, pointing out that other, more controversial celebrations, such as simulating gunshots or throat-slitting, often go unpunished. Critics argue that Ndiaye's celebration was far from offensive and that it is a harmless expression of joy.

"It's ridiculous that players are allowed to simulate shooting guns or slitting throats, but not flap their arms like wings," said one fan on social media. "This is political correctness gone mad."

Others have suggested that Ndiaye's celebration may have been misinterpreted. Some argue that he was imitating a gannet, a seabird found in the North Atlantic, or even the African spoonbill, the national bird of his native Senegal. There is even speculation that he was paying homage to "Angry Birds," a former sponsor of Everton.

The Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL), the body responsible for refereeing in English football, has defended Robinson's decision, stating that Ndiaye's celebration was "intended to provoke" Brighton's players and fans. However, this explanation has done little to quell the controversy.

"This is just another example of the PGMOL being out of touch with the modern game," said former Premier League referee Mark Clattenburg. "Ndiaye's celebration was harmless and should not have been punished."

The incident has also raised questions about freedom of expression in football. Some argue that players should be allowed to celebrate goals in any way they see fit, as long as their actions are not offensive or discriminatory. Others believe that there should be some limits on goal celebrations, but that Ndiaye's actions did not cross the line.

"Football is a game of passion and emotion," said former England international Gary Lineker. "Players should be allowed to express themselves, as long as they are not causing harm to others."

The debate over Ndiaye's celebration is likely to continue for some time. In the meantime, the incident has highlighted the need for greater clarity and consistency in the application of the laws of the game.