[GLOBAL ECONOMIC TIMES] “I can’t remember because I drank too much.” This phrase, which often appears at crime scenes, clearly shows the complex relationship between drinking and crime. Attempts to have the sentence reduced by claiming to be mentally and physically weak after drinking continue, causing social controversy. Can drinking really be an excuse for all crimes? In order to find a clear answer to this question, it is necessary to first understand what mental and physical weakness is and in what cases the sentence can be reduced.
Weakness of mind and body refers to a state in which the ability to discriminate between objects or make decisions is significantly reduced due to alcohol or drugs. In other words, it is argued that because the person was insane at the time of the crime, the capacity for full responsibility was absent or greatly reduced. The criminal law provides that if a crime is committed while mentally or physically weak, the sentence may be reduced or exempted.
However, in order to be recognized as mentally and physically weak, several conditions must be met. First, it must be proven that the person was actually mentally and physically weak at the time of the crime. Simply saying that you drank alcohol is not enough; you must provide concrete evidence through medical diagnosis or eyewitness testimony. In addition, it must be proven that the degree of mental and physical weakness had a significant influence on the crime. In other words, it must be shown that it is highly likely that the person did not commit the crime due to mental or physical weakness, or that the details of the crime have seriously changed.
Drinking alcohol is one of the important factors that increases the incidence of crime. This is because when you are drunk, your judgment becomes clouded and you are prone to impulsive actions. In particular, crimes such as sexual violence, violence, and drunk driving are closely related to drinking. However, not all alcohol-related crimes are recognized as mentally and physically weak.
The claim of mental and physical weakness raises several problems. First, criticism is raised that the punishment is too lenient on criminals. This means that they ignore the pain of the victims and take lightly only the responsibility of the criminal. Second, it is very difficult to determine whether a person is mentally or physically weak. An accurate medical diagnosis is required, and the judge's subjective judgment is likely to be involved. Third, there is a court precedent that does not recognize mental or physical weakness in cases where a person commits a crime despite being able to anticipate and refrain from drinking in advance.
Weakness of mind and body after drinking cannot be an excuse for all crimes. Whether a person is mentally and physically weak must be determined by comprehensively considering various factors, such as the circumstances at the time of the crime, the details of the crime, and the defendant's past actions. In addition, institutional improvements are needed to prevent attempts to reduce punishment by exploiting mental and physical weakness.
[Copyright (c) Global Economic Times. All Rights Reserved.]
